David Rosenberg did an exceptional job in his article in Monday’s Globe and Mail :
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/investment-ideas/features/experts-podium/can-both-the-economists-and-strategists-be-right/article1434137/
Essentially, he pinpoints how blatently the S&P 500 missed its aggregate earnings “estimate”, yet the market continues to make new highs:
“Forget all the calculations off the “artificial” March lows. Forget the 25 per-cent market slide in the first 10 weeks of the year to that awful trough. Here is the reality: The S&P 500, from point to point, rallied 23 per cent in 2009 even though earnings per share for the year as a whole cam in at a whopping $21 less than first estimated.
Now that is remarkable. It almost wants to make you believe in the tooth fairy. ”
The operating earnings estimate for the S&P 500 coming into 2009 was $77. For the actual earnings to come in at $56, is a 27% decline in earnings ! Now you tell me…….if you were invested in a good company stock, say Royal Bank, and they released earnings down 27% from the estimate, do you really think a rally of 23% in the stock would occur, or be justified ?
The S&P 500 is highly overvalued. The masses can feel good that the US has avoided a more severe recession, than might otherwise have happened, without a Fed throwing trillions of dollars at the economy. US economic reality will set in , sometime in 2010. Rest assured, the serious problems of very high unemployment, growing mortgage defaults and foreclosures, high and growing government deficits, will have to be addressed (when it comes to calculating any “real” recovery). The great news is that those investors that have taken measures to protect their portfolios, will have another great selection of investment opportunities (no diffferent than last year at this time, when you could have bought Oil, Gold, the S&P 500, TSX, China …….etc.)
For the next series of “blogs”, I will be discussing exactly where to invest , once this overdue correction is upon us.
Best regards,
Mike McGann
Director, Wealth Advisor



